In AP African American Studies 2.21 students are expected to:
- Explain the significance of visual depictions of African American leaders in photography and art during and after the era of slavery.
Photography as Resistance
With the rise of photography in the 19th century, African American leaders recognized its potential to combat racist portrayals and affirm Black humanity. Photography allowed them to control their own representation, countering the degrading caricatures that were prevalent in popular media.

How African American Leaders Used Photography:
- Presented themselves as dignified, intelligent, and respectable individuals to demand equal rights.
- Used formal portraits—wearing elegant clothing and maintaining serious expressions—to challenge stereotypes of Black inferiority.
- Distributed images widely to shape public opinion and advocate for social and political change.
Notable Figures in Photography:
- Frederick Douglass – The most photographed man of the 19th century, he curated his image to reflect intellect, leadership, and respectability.
- Sojourner Truth – Sold carte-de-visite photographs of herself to fund abolitionist efforts and promote the leadership role of Black women.
Sojourner Truth’s Carte-De-Visites
Sojourner Truth, a formerly enslaved woman turned abolitionist and women's rights activist, strategically used photography to fund and further her activism.
How Truth Used Photography for Activism:
- Sold carte-de-visite photographs to raise money for the abolitionist movement.
- Used her portraits to convey strength, intelligence, and moral conviction—challenging racist portrayals of Black women.
- Used the revenue to support speaking tours, abolitionist efforts, and the recruitment of Black soldiers for the Union Army during the Civil War.
📸 Carte-de-Visites Explained:
- Small, affordable photographs that became widely popular in the mid-19th century.
- Truth’s images often showed her seated, wearing a cap and shawl, with a stern expression—symbolizing her resilience and dedication to justice.
Impact: Truth’s images helped redefine Black womanhood and reinforced the crucial role of Black women in the fight for abolition and equality.
Frederick Douglass's Photographic Legacy
Frederick Douglass, a formerly enslaved man who became one of the most influential abolitionists, was the most photographed man of the 19th century. He recognized photography’s power to reshape the narrative surrounding Black identity.
Douglass's Views on Photography:
✔️ Believed photography provided visual proof of African American dignity and intelligence.
✔️ Used his portraits to challenge racist depictions and present himself as a statesman and intellectual.
✔️ Advocated for photography as a tool for social and political change, inspiring African Americans to see themselves as capable and deserving of freedom.
📷 Key Features of Douglass’s Photographs:
- Always appeared well-dressed, with a serious and composed demeanor.
- Avoided smiling to counter stereotypes of African Americans as unintelligent or subservient.
- Sat for more than 160 portraits, outnumbering even President Abraham Lincoln.
Impact: Douglass’s photographic legacy set a precedent for Black leaders using visual imagery as a form of resistance and empowerment.
Contemporary Art and the Legacy of Black Representation
Even today, artists continue using visual art to honor and represent Black leaders, drawing from Black cultural traditions, historical events, and themes of resistance.
How Contemporary Artists Depict Black Leadership:
🎨 Use symbolism, motifs, and styles rooted in African and African American heritage.
🎨 Highlight historical, religious, and gender perspectives in their representations.
🎨 Ensure that the stories of Black leaders remain visible, celebrated, and educational.
Examples of Contemporary African American Artists:
🖌 Kehinde Wiley – Painted the official portrait of President Barack Obama, merging European portraiture styles with African American themes.
🖌 Amy Sherald – Created the official portrait of First Lady Michelle Obama, emphasizing modern Black womanhood with unique grayscale tones and geometric compositions.
These modern depictions of Black leadership ensure that the fight for equality, dignity, and recognition continues to inspire future generations.
Required Sources
Carte-de-Visite Portrait of Harriet Tubman, 1868-1869
Harriet Tubman's portrait captures the image of an iconic abolitionist and conductor of the Underground Railroad. This visual representation provides a rare glimpse into the appearance and demeanor of a woman who risked her life repeatedly to lead enslaved people to freedom.
The carte-de-visite format made Tubman's likeness widely accessible, helping to spread awareness of her heroic deeds and the broader abolitionist cause. This photograph serves as a powerful symbol of resistance against slavery and the fight for African American liberation during the 19th century.
Matte Collodion Print of Harriet Tubman, 1871-1876
Harriet Tubman's image captured in this rare 19th century photograph provides a powerful visual representation of one of the most iconic figures in African American history. As a formerly enslaved woman who became a legendary conductor on the Underground Railroad, Tubman embodied courage and resistance against the institution of slavery.
The photograph serves as a tangible connection to Tubman's era, offering insight into her appearance and presence during a pivotal time in American history. It stands as a testament to her enduring legacy as an abolitionist, Civil War spy, and advocate for women's suffrage, inspiring generations in the ongoing struggle for civil rights and equality.
Albumen Print of Harriet Tubman, Circa 1908
Harriet Tubman's image captured in this early 20th century photograph serves as a powerful visual testament to her enduring legacy as an abolitionist, Underground Railroad conductor, and civil rights pioneer. The portrait preserves her likeness for future generations, providing a tangible connection to one of the most influential African American figures in history.
This photograph holds significant educational value in African American studies courses, offering students a rare glimpse of Tubman in her later years. It prompts discussions about her remarkable life, from her escape from slavery to her tireless efforts in guiding others to freedom, and her continued activism well into the post-Civil War era.
I Go to Prepare a Place for You by Bisa Butler, 2021
This vibrant textile artwork by contemporary African American artist Bisa Butler represents a powerful reclamation of Black history and identity. Through her distinctive quilting technique, Butler transforms archival photographs into colorful, life-sized portraits that celebrate the dignity and humanity of her subjects.
The piece speaks to themes of ancestry, migration, and the African American experience. By reimagining historical figures in vivid hues and patterns, Butler challenges traditional narratives and brings marginalized stories to the forefront, encouraging viewers to engage with the complexities of Black culture and heritage.
💡 Takeaways 💡
- Photography served as a tool of resistance, allowing African American leaders to challenge racist portrayals and assert their dignity.
- Sojourner Truth used carte-de-visite photographs to fund abolitionist causes and redefine the image of Black women.
- Frederick Douglass recognized photography’s power and became the most photographed man of the 19th century, shaping how Black leadership was perceived.
- Contemporary artists continue the tradition of using visual representation to celebrate Black leaders and their legacies.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a carte-de-visite and why did African American leaders use them?
A carte-de-visite was a small, inexpensive photographic print mounted on a card (about the size of a calling card) that became hugely popular in the mid-1800s because studios could mass-produce multiple copies. African American leaders used cartes-de-visite to shape public images and fight racist stereotypes: photos presented them as dignified, respectable citizens deserving of rights (EK 2.21.A.1). They were also tools for fundraising and activism—Sojourner Truth sold her cartes-de-visite to raise money for abolition and recruiting (EK 2.21.A.2), and Frederick Douglass used repeated portraits to spread his image and message (EK 2.21.A.3). Because cartes were cheap, portable, and easily shared, they helped circulate visual proof of Black achievement and freedom. For more on this topic, see the AP Topic 2.21 study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe). For practice, check Fiveable’s unit resources (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2) and practice questions (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
Why was Frederick Douglass the most photographed man of the 19th century?
Frederick Douglass became the most photographed man of the nineteenth century because he used photography as a political tool to shape how Black people were seen. He sat for dozens of portraits over many decades—cartes-de-visite and studio portraits that showed him dignified, educated, and respectable—explicitly to counter racist stereotypes and prove Black citizenship and achievement (EK 2.21.A.1, EK 2.21.A.3). Photos helped him promote speaking tours, books, and abolitionist fundraising; different poses and repeated images kept his public identity visible across the North and overseas. For AP exam prep, this ties to visual self-representation and how leaders used new media to argue for equal rights (see the Topic 2.21 study guide on Fiveable: https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe). For extra practice on visuals, try Fiveable’s practice bank (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
How did photography help counter racist stereotypes about Black people during slavery?
Photography let Black leaders control how they were seen. In the 1800s new formats like the carte-de-visite and collodion and albumen prints let people such as Frederick Douglass, Sojourner Truth, and Harriet Tubman present themselves as dignified, literate citizens—not the racist caricatures common in popular media. Douglass’s many portraits and Tubman’s images showed formerly enslaved people who’d achieved freedom and leadership; Truth sold cartes-de-visite to fund abolition and her speaking tours. These photos were used in abolitionist campaigns, fundraising, and public lectures to prove Black competence, moral worth, and right to equal rights (LO 2.21.A, EK 2.21.A.1–A.3). For AP prep, be ready to explain how photographic self-representation challenged stereotypes and supported political goals—the topic study guide here covers this (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe). For more practice, try Fiveable’s unit review and practice problems (https://library.fiveable.me/unit-2, https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
What did Sojourner Truth do with her photographs besides just taking them?
Sojourner Truth didn’t just sit for photos—she used them as activism and fundraising tools. She sold small portrait prints called carte-de-visites to raise money for the abolitionist cause and to support her speaking tours. Her photos also helped recruit Black soldiers for the Union and circulated widely to show that Black women were public leaders deserving of dignity and respect. In short, her photographic self-representation was political: it countered racist stereotypes, raised funds, boosted her visibility as an organizer and speaker, and reinforced Black women's central leadership in the fight for freedom (see the Topic 2.21 study guide: https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe). For extra practice connecting visuals to AP-style questions, check Fiveable’s practice problems (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
I'm confused about how taking photos was considered resistance - can someone explain this?
Taking photos was resistance because people used the new medium to control how Black leaders and formerly enslaved people were seen—not as stereotypes but as dignified citizens deserving rights. That’s exactly LO 2.21.A in the CED: 19th-century Black leaders embraced photography to counter racist images (EK 2.21.A.1). Examples: Sojourner Truth sold carte-de-visites to fund abolition and show Black women’s leadership (EK 2.21.A.2); Frederick Douglass—the most photographed man of the century—used portraits to prove Black achievement (EK 2.21.A.3); photos of Harriet Tubman documented freedom and leadership. Later artists like Bisa Butler quilt portraits that reclaim and deepen those legacies (EK 2.21.A.4). For the AP exam, be ready to explain how photographic self-representation challenged stereotypes and supported abolitionist work—use the topic study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe) and practice questions (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
Why were photos of formerly enslaved people like Harriet Tubman so significant?
Photos of formerly enslaved people like Harriet Tubman mattered because they turned a new technology—photography—into political proof. By sitting for cartes-de-visite, albumen, and collodion portraits, Tubman and others (like Frederick Douglass, the most photographed man of the 19th century) used photographic self-representation to contradict racist stereotypes and show Black people as dignified citizens deserving of equal rights (CED EK 2.21.A.1, EK 2.21.A.3). Tubman’s images also tied into abolitionist work: portraits helped raise funds, promoted her leadership as a Black woman, and made the achievements of formerly enslaved people visible—evidence of freedom’s possibilities. Contemporary artists (e.g., Bisa Butler) build on that legacy to preserve stories of resistance and faith. For review, check Topic 2.21’s study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe) and practice questions (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
How do modern African American artists like Bisa Butler connect to historical Black leaders?
Modern artists like Bisa Butler connect to historical Black leaders by reworking visual traditions that nineteenth-century leaders used to claim dignity and leadership. Butler’s quilted portrait I Go to Prepare a Place for You centers Harriet Tubman, using African American quilting techniques, diasporic patterns, and religious symbolism to highlight Tubman’s faith, leadership, and resistance (EK 2.21.A.4). That mirrors how Sojourner Truth and Frederick Douglass used carte-de-visite and other photographic formats to fundraise, assert citizenship, and counter racist stereotypes (EK 2.21.A.1–3). Butler transforms photographic self-representation into tactile, large-scale quilted images that preserve leaders’ legacies and connect Black aesthetic traditions to gender, religious, and diasporic themes—exactly the kinds of continuities the AP CED asks you to explain for LO 2.21.A. For a quick refresher on this topic, check the Topic 2.21 study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe) and practice questions (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
What's the difference between how Sojourner Truth and Frederick Douglass used photography for activism?
Sojourner Truth and Frederick Douglass both used photography to push back against racist stereotypes, but they did it in different, strategic ways. Truth sold carte-de-visite portraits to raise money for abolition, to publicize her speaking tours, and to highlight Black women's leadership (CED EK 2.21.A.2). Her images circulated as fundraising and promotional tools tied to activism. Douglass, meanwhile, became the nineteenth century’s most photographed man; his portraits were deliberately dignified and widely reproduced to show that formerly enslaved people could be accomplished citizens deserving of equal rights (CED EK 2.21.A.1, A.3). In short: Truth used photography as a fundraising and organizing tool that centered Black women’s leadership; Douglass used repeated, carefully staged portraits to normalize Black achievement and claim full civic dignity. (See the Topic 2.21 study guide: https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe.) For more practice on CED-aligned questions, try Fiveable’s practice problems (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
How did African American leaders use new technology to fight for civil rights in the 1800s?
In the 1800s African American leaders used photography—a brand-new tech—to shape public opinion and push for rights. They sat for carte-de-visite and other prints to show Black dignity, counter racist stereotypes, and prove formerly enslaved people could be respected citizens (EK 2.21.A.1). Sojourner Truth sold her cartes-de-visite to raise money for abolition, speak on tours, and recruit Black soldiers (EK 2.21.A.2). Frederick Douglass was the most photographed man of the century; images of him and Harriet Tubman showed Black achievement and freedom, strengthening abolitionist arguments and inspiring supporters (EK 2.21.A.3). These photos were evidence activists used in speeches, fundraising, and posters—an early media strategy to influence Northern audiences and policy. For more on this topic, check the Topic 2.21 study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe). For practice, try problems at (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
What are Black aesthetic traditions and how do contemporary artists use them?
Black aesthetic traditions are visual and material practices—like quilted portraiture, photo self-representation, and diasporic symbolism—rooted in African American craft, religion, history, and gendered experience. They show resilience: 19th-century leaders used cartes-de-visite, collodion, and albumen prints to claim dignity and counter racist stereotypes (see Douglass, Truth, Tubman). Contemporary artists build on those traditions by reworking materials and iconography to connect past and present. For example, Bisa Butler’s quilted portraits (I Go to Prepare a Place for You) use African American quilting, religious imagery, and African motifs to honor Harriet Tubman’s leadership and faith while making the work tactile and public. On the AP exam, be ready to explain how visual choices (medium, composition, symbols) preserve legacies of resistance and show continuity/change across time (LO 2.21.A, EK 2.21.A.4). For more detail, check the Topic 2.21 study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe), Unit 2 overview (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2), and practice questions (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
Can someone explain how Bisa Butler's quilts relate to African American resistance?
Bisa Butler’s quilts relate to African American resistance by using quilted portraiture to reclaim and celebrate Black leadership and dignity—the same goal nineteenth-century Black photographers had when they used new technology to counter racist stereotypes (EK 2.21.A.1–.3). In I Go to Prepare a Place for You Butler reimagines Harriet Tubman through African American quilting traditions, diasporic patterns, and religious symbolism to highlight Tubman’s faith, leadership, and bravery (EK 2.21.A.4). Her work is tactile and public: it preserves memory, centers Black women’s roles in abolition, and resists erasure by making history visible in a medium tied to communal labor and survival. For the AP exam, you can connect Butler’s quilt to the required Tubman photos by explaining how both art and photography function as forms of visual self-representation and resistance (see the Topic 2.21 study guide: https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe). For extra practice, check Fiveable’s practice problems (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
Why did photos of Black people matter so much when most people couldn't even read back then?
Photos mattered because pictures worked where words couldn’t. In the 19th century many people had limited literacy, but nearly everyone could see a photograph and instantly read its message: dignity, freedom, leadership. African American leaders like Frederick Douglass and Sojourner Truth used new formats (carte-de-visite, albumen prints) that were cheap, reproducible, and portable—perfect for fundraising, recruiting Black soldiers, and circulating abolitionist messages. Photos countered racist stereotypes by showing formerly enslaved people as respectable citizens worthy of rights, and they created visual evidence of Black achievement that newspapers, lectures, and exhibitions could amplify. That visual power carries into contemporary art (e.g., Bisa Butler’s quilted portraits) which preserves and reinterprets those legacies. On the AP exam you might see this in a short-answer visual source or the project (LO 2.21.A); the topic study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe) and practice problems (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies) are great for drilling this.
How do I write an essay about visual representations of African American leadership?
Start with a clear thesis: what claim are you making about visual representations of Black leadership (e.g., “Photography and quilted portraiture reframed African American leaders as dignified citizens and carriers of collective memory”)? Then structure your essay: - Context (1 paragraph): situate images historically—19th-century embrace of photography (carte-de-visite, matte collodion, albumen prints) to counter stereotypes (EK 2.21.A.1–A.3). - Description + evidence (2 paragraphs): closely describe 2–3 images (e.g., Douglass’s portraits, Sojourner Truth’s cartes used for abolition fundraising, Bisa Butler’s I Go to Prepare a Place for You). Name dates, formats, and one visual detail per source that supports your claim. - Analysis (1 paragraph): explain purpose, audience, and how each image resists white narratives (self-representation, Black women’s leadership, diasporic symbolism). Tie Butler to Black aesthetic/quilting traditions (EK 2.21.A.4). - Comparison & significance (1 paragraph): compare strategies across media and explain long-term legacies (representation, memory, political mobilization). Remember AP requirements: cite each source by name, offer at least two explicit comparisons, and support claims with specific evidence (use the Selected Sources Template for your project). For review/examples, check the Topic 2.21 study guide (Fiveable) (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe) and practice questions (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).
What was the connection between photography and the abolitionist movement?
Photography was a powerful tool for the abolitionist movement because images let Black leaders control how they were seen. Nineteenth-century technologies like the carte-de-visite, matte collodion, and albumen prints helped people such as Frederick Douglass (the most photographed man of the century), Harriet Tubman, and Sojourner Truth present themselves as dignified citizens deserving of rights (EK 2.21.A.1, A.3). Sojourner Truth sold carte-de-visites to raise money for abolition and recruitment; Tubman’s and Douglass’s portraits proved that formerly enslaved people could succeed in freedom, countering racist stereotypes (EK 2.21.A.2–3). Those photographs were used in lectures, fund-raising, and newspapers to persuade Northern audiences and build credibility. For AP prep, study the required photos in Topic 2.21 and use the Fiveable study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe) and practice questions (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies) to link images to abolitionist strategies for the exam.
I don't understand how art and photography preserve legacies of resistance - help?
Art and photography preserve legacies of resistance by making Black leadership and dignity visible—and by controlling the story. In the 19th century, leaders like Frederick Douglass and Sojourner Truth used photographic self-representation (carte-de-visite, albumen, matte collodion prints) to counter racist stereotypes, raise money (Truth’s cartes), recruit soldiers, and show that formerly enslaved people were citizens worthy of respect (LO 2.21.A; EKs 2.21.A.1–3). Contemporary artists build on those visual traditions: Bisa Butler’s quilted portrait I Go to Prepare a Place for You reinterprets Tubman’s leadership through quilting, diasporic symbolism, religion, and gender (EK 2.21.A.4). For the AP exam/project, use these images as primary sources—cite specific details, explain purpose/audience, and compare how older photos and modern art each preserve resistance (this fits Skill 2: Source Analysis and Skill 3: Argumentation). For more examples and review, see the Topic 2.21 study guide (https://library.fiveable.me/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/21-legacies-of-resistance-in-african-american-art-and-photography/study-guide/i6dgSRQeJckJJ4Qe) and practice questions (https://library.fiveable.me/practice/ap-african-american-studies).