In AP African American Studies 2.18 students are expected to:

1. Explain how nineteenth-century emigrationists aimed to achieve the goal of Black freedom and self-determination.
2. Explain how transatlantic abolitionism influenced anti-emigrationists’ political views about the potential for African Americans’ belonging in American society

---

African Americans in the 19th century debated whether to stay in the U.S. or emigrate to other countries for freedom. Emigrationists saw promise in Latin America, the Caribbean, and West Africa, while anti-emigrationists believed in fighting for rights at home.

The debate highlighted complex issues of citizenship, identity, and belonging. It reflected broader struggles for abolition and equality, with leaders on both sides shaping Black political thought and activism in America and beyond.

Emigration: Black Freedom?

What is Emigrationism?

Emigrationism was a movement led by Black advocates who believed that true Black nationalism, unity, pride, and self-determination could only be achieved if African Americans emigrated—or relocated—outside of the United States. Emigrationists argued that systemic racism, political disenfranchisement, and economic oppression in the U.S. created insurmountable barriers to Black progress, making it necessary to seek freedom and opportunity elsewhere.

The movement gained traction as African Americans observed the abolition of slavery in Latin America and the Caribbean before it was abolished in the U.S. These examples inspired African American emigrationists, who saw these regions as proof that societies free from slavery and racial discrimination could exist. The Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857) Supreme Court decision, which ruled that African Americans were not U.S. citizens and had no constitutional rights, further reinforced the idea that Black self-determination within the United States was impossible.

Identifying New Homelands

Emigrationists sought to establish Black communities in regions with significant Afro-descendant populations, shared histories of resistance against slavery, and favorable climates. Latin America, the Caribbean, and West Africa were considered prime destinations for relocation due to their cultural ties to the African diaspora and their histories of Black-led independence movements.

Among the most popular destinations were:

• Haiti: The first independent Black republic, established after the successful Haitian Revolution (1791-1804). Its commitment to Black sovereignty made it an attractive destination for African Americans seeking freedom.
• Liberia: Founded by the American Colonization Society (ACS) in 1822 as a colony for freed African Americans, Liberia was envisioned as a place where Black people could govern themselves, free from white oppression.
• Sierra Leone: Established by the British in the late 18th century as a settlement for freed African Americans and formerly enslaved people from the Caribbean and Britain.

Black Nationalism and Emigration

Black abolitionists who supported emigration often embraced Black nationalism, advocating for racial pride, unity, and self-governance. They believed that African Americans should establish independent communities outside the U.S. rather than continue to struggle against the deeply entrenched racism of American society.

While some African Americans strongly supported emigration, others, including figures like Frederick Douglass, opposed the movement. They argued that African Americans had the right to fight for equality and justice within the United States rather than leave the country that they had helped build.

The debate over emigration reflected broader discussions about the best path to Black liberation: whether to demand rights and inclusion in American society or to seek freedom and self-rule elsewhere.

Emigrationist Leaders

Throughout the 19th century, several prominent Black leaders championed emigration as a solution to the systemic racism and oppression African Americans faced in the United States. These leaders believed that Black people could only achieve self-determination and sovereignty by establishing independent Black-led communities outside of the U.S.

Martin R. Delany: The Father of Black Nationalism

• Martin R. Delany was a Black abolitionist, physician, and one of the first African Americans admitted to Harvard Medical School. He is often considered the "Father of Black Nationalism."
• Delany argued that African Americans would never achieve true equality in the United States due to the deeply entrenched racism of white society.
• He strongly advocated for the establishment of a Black nation in Africa or the Caribbean, where African Americans could govern themselves free from white oppression.

Henry Highland Garnet: Minister and Militant Emigrationist

• Henry Highland Garnet, a fiery abolitionist and Presbyterian minister, was another leading advocate for Black emigration and nationalism.
• He believed African Americans should build their own independent nation rather than continue to endure systemic racism in the United States.
• Garnet co-founded the African Civilization Society, which promoted emigration to Liberia as a means for African Americans to escape racial oppression and help develop the African continent.

Edward Wilmot Blyden: The Intellectual Architect of Pan-Africanism

• Edward Wilmot Blyden, a Liberian scholar, politician, and diplomat, became one of the most influential advocates of Pan-Africanism and emigration.
• Blyden believed that African Americans could only achieve true freedom, dignity, and self-determination by returning to Africa.
• He argued that Africa was the ancestral homeland of all people of African descent and that African Americans had a duty to contribute to its development—both politically and economically.

Paul Cuffee: The First Black Emigrationist

• Paul Cuffee, a wealthy Black Quaker, merchant, and shipowner, was one of the earliest proponents of African American emigration.
• In 1815, he personally financed and led a mission to relocate 39 free African Americans to Freetown, Sierra Leone, a British colony established for freed enslaved people.
• Cuffee believed that Africa offered a greater opportunity for freedom and self-governance than the racially hostile United States.

Cuffee Establishing a Black Settlement in Sierra Leone

• Cuffee’s group included skilled artisans, farmers, and teachers, who hoped to use their talents to contribute to the economic development of Sierra Leone.
• Many emigrants were motivated not only by a desire for freedom but also by a mission to spread Christianity and introduce Western-style education.
• Despite initial challenges, the settlement survived and grew, inspiring future Black emigration movements and setting a precedent for later efforts to relocate African Americans to Africa.

Transatlantic Abolitionism vs. Emigration

Anti-Emigrationist Beliefs and the Fight for Citizenship

Not all African Americans supported emigration. Anti-emigrationists believed that the fight for abolition and racial equality should take place within the United States, as African Americans had a right to full citizenship.

• Many abolitionists emphasized the idea of "birthright citizenship"—the belief that African Americans were entitled to the same rights and privileges as white Americans by virtue of being born in the U.S.
• They argued that leaving the country would be a surrender to white supremacy and would abandon the struggle for equal rights.

Frederick Douglass: The Strongest Voice Against Emigration

• Frederick Douglass, a formerly enslaved abolitionist and writer, was one of the most vocal opponents of Black emigration.
• He argued that African Americans had a right to live and prosper in the land of their birth and that leaving the U.S. would weaken the fight for racial justice.

William Lloyd Garrison: A White Abolitionist Opponent of Emigration

• William Lloyd Garrison, a white abolitionist and founder of the American Anti-Slavery Society, also opposed emigration.
• He believed the U.S. had a moral obligation to abolish slavery and grant full citizenship rights to African Americans rather than encourage them to leave.

The Fugitive Slave Acts and Black Refugees in Europe

The Fugitive Slave Acts: Escaping Slavery Across the Atlantic

• The Fugitive Slave Acts of 1793 and 1850 allowed the capture and return of runaway enslaved people, even in free states.
• This meant that formerly enslaved abolitionists like Frederick Douglass could still be recaptured and re-enslaved, even in the North.
• As a result, many Black abolitionists sought refuge in England and Ireland, where they were free from U.S. laws that threatened their freedom.

Black Abolitionists in Exile

While in Europe, Black abolitionists continued to fight for the abolition of slavery:

• They lectured, wrote articles, and raised funds for the abolitionist movement in the U.S.
• Their international advocacy helped build global opposition to slavery and increased pressure on the U.S. government.

Notable Black Abolitionists Who Found Refuge in Europe

• Henry Box Brown: Famously escaped slavery by mailing himself in a wooden crate from Virginia to Philadelphia.
• William Wells Brown: Became a prolific abolitionist writer and lecturer while living in England.
• Ellen and William Craft: Escaped slavery by disguising Ellen as a white male plantation owner and William as her enslaved servant.

The Paradox of American Independence

America’s Hypocrisy: Slavery vs. Freedom

• Anti-emigrationists highlighted the contradiction between American ideals of freedom and its continued oppression of African Americans.
• They argued that celebrating American independence while denying millions of African Americans citizenship and basic rights was deeply hypocritical.
• The Declaration of Independence's claim that "all men are created equal" rang hollow in a nation where African Americans were treated as property.

The Dred Scott Decision and the Denial of Citizenship

• The Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857) Supreme Court decision ruled that:
  • African Americans, whether free or enslaved, could never be U.S. citizens.
  • This decision effectively stripped African Americans of all legal protections under the Constitution.
• Anti-emigrationists viewed this ruling as further proof that African Americans needed to fight for their rights within the United States rather than abandon the struggle.

The Economic Hypocrisy of Slavery

• Anti-emigrationists pointed out that the United States’ economic prosperity was built on enslaved African labor.
• They argued that white Americans celebrated the nation's wealth and progress while ignoring the immense human cost of slavery.
• Abolitionists like Frederick Douglass and Sojourner Truth emphasized that America’s moral and spiritual well-being was compromised by its reliance on slavery.

Required Sources

"Emigration to Mexico" by "A Colored Female of Philadelphia," The Liberator, 1832

This letter published in The Liberator newspaper provides a rare firsthand account from an African American woman considering emigration to Mexico in the early 19th century. It offers valuable insight into the complex decisions and motivations of free Black individuals seeking opportunities outside the United States during a time of increasing racial tensions.

The author's perspective illuminates the broader context of African American emigration movements in the antebellum period. Her contemplation of Mexico as a destination highlights the diverse strategies employed by Black Americans to escape oppression and pursue freedom, challenging the notion that emigration efforts were solely focused on Africa or Canada.

Excerpt from The Condition, Elevation, Emigration, and Destiny of the Colored People of the United States, Politically Considered by Martin R. Delany, 1852

Martin R. Delany's work represents a seminal contribution to early African American political thought and activism. As one of the first major texts to advocate for black nationalism and emigration, it challenged prevailing notions about the place of African Americans in U.S. society and offered a radical vision for black self-determination.

The document's significance lies in its articulation of a distinct black political identity and its call for African Americans to consider alternatives to integration within the United States. Delany's ideas influenced later Pan-African movements and helped lay the intellectual groundwork for Marcus Garvey's Back-to-Africa movement in the early 20th century.

• Historical precedent for beneficial emigration
  • "That there have been people in all ages under certain circumstances, that may be benefited by emigration, will be admitted; and that there are circumstances under which emigration is absolutely necessary to their political elevation, cannot be disputed."
  • This quote establishes that emigration has historically been beneficial and sometimes necessary for certain groups.
• Examples of significant historical emigrations
  • "This we see in the Exodus of the Jews from Egypt to the land of Judea; in the expedition of Dido and her followers from Tyro to Mauritania; and [...] in the ever memorable emigration of the Puritans, in 1620, from Great Britain [...] to the wilderness of the New World"
  • The author provides specific examples to support the historical precedent for beneficial emigration.
• Novel proposal for colored people's emigration
  • "[T]o advocate the emigration of the colored people of the United States from their native homes, is a new feature in our history, and at first view, may be considered objectionable, as pernicious to our interests."
  • This quote acknowledges that proposing emigration for colored people from the US is a new and potentially controversial idea.
• Justification for emigration based on current conditions
  • "This objection is at once removed, when reflecting on our condition as incontrovertibly shown in a foregoing part of this work."
  • The author suggests that the current conditions of colored people in the US justify considering emigration.
• Importance of choosing the right destination
  • "Where shall we go? This we conceive to be all important—of paramount consideration"
  • This quote emphasizes the critical nature of selecting an appropriate destination for emigration.
• Opposition to Liberian colonization
  • "[P]remise the recommendation, with the strictest advice against any countenance whatever, to the emigration scheme of the so called Republic of Liberia."
  • The author strongly advises against supporting the Liberian colonization scheme, indicating a preference for other emigration options.

"West India Emancipation" by Frederick Douglass, 1857

Frederick Douglass's "West India Emancipation" speech delivered in 1857 stands as a powerful critique of American slavery, using the successful abolition of slavery in the British West Indies as a model. Douglass's oratory skills and persuasive arguments highlighted the moral imperative of emancipation and the potential for peaceful transition to a free society.

The speech serves as a crucial primary source for understanding the abolitionist movement and the intellectual foundations of the fight against slavery. Douglass's work exemplifies how African American leaders utilized international examples to challenge the institution of slavery in the United States, demonstrating the global context of the struggle for freedom and equality.

Summarized:

• The significance of West India Emancipation
  • "The event we celebrate is the finding and the restoration to the broken ranks of human brotherhood, eight hundred thousand lost members of the human family."
  • This quote emphasizes the moral importance of emancipation, framing it as a restoration of human dignity.
• Criticism of America's response to West India Emancipation
  • "As a nation, we are deaf, dumb, and blind to the moral beauty and transcendent sublimity of West India Emancipation."
  • Douglass criticizes the American response, highlighting the nation's inability to appreciate the moral significance of the event.
• The materialistic American perspective on emancipation
  • "Will it pay? Will it increase the growth of sugar? Will it cheapen tobacco?"
  • These questions illustrate the narrow, economic focus of American critiques of emancipation, ignoring its human and moral aspects.
• The importance of struggle in achieving progress
  • "If there is no struggle there is no progress. Those who profess to favor freedom and yet deprecate agitation, are men who want crops without plowing up the ground"
  • Douglass argues that meaningful change requires active struggle and cannot be achieved passively.
• The role of slave resistance in achieving emancipation
  • "Though slaves, they were rebellious slaves... They did not hug their chains, but according to their opportunities, swelled the general protest against oppression."
  • This quote acknowledges the active role played by enslaved people in their own liberation, countering narratives that focus solely on the actions of white abolitionists.
• The interconnected nature of British and American abolitionism
  • "The abolition movement in America, like many other institutions of this country, was largely derived from England."
  • Douglass points out the transnational nature of abolitionism, highlighting the influence of British ideas and tactics on the American movement.
• The need for African American self-assertion and leadership
  • "I hold it to be no part of gratitude to allow our white friends to do all the work, while we merely hold their coats."
  • This quote emphasizes Douglass's belief in the importance of African American agency and leadership within the abolitionist movement.

---

💡Takeaways💡

• Emigrationist Leaders: Advocates for African American emigration due to systemic racism and oppression in the U.S.
  • Martin R. Delany: A Black abolitionist who argued that African Americans could never achieve true equality in the U.S. and promoted the establishment of a Black nation in Africa or the Caribbean.
  • Henry Highland Garnet: Supported Black nationalism and founded the African Civilization Society to promote emigration to Liberia.
  • Edward Wilmot Blyden: A Pan-Africanist who believed African Americans should return to Africa to achieve true freedom and contribute to its development.
• Paul Cuffee's Sierra Leone Mission: The first organized emigration mission for African Americans.
  • In 1815, Paul Cuffee, a wealthy Black Quaker, led 39 African Americans to Sierra Leone to establish a settlement in Freetown.
  • The settlers included skilled artisans, farmers, and teachers who contributed to developing the settlement and spreading Christianity.
  • Cuffee’s success inspired further emigration projects for African Americans seeking freedom in Africa.
• Anti-Emigrationist Beliefs: Advocates for racial equality within the U.S. who argued that African Americans were entitled to birthright citizenship.
  • Frederick Douglass: A vocal opponent of emigration who believed that African Americans should fight for equality within the U.S. rather than abandon the struggle.
  • William Lloyd Garrison: A white abolitionist who argued that the U.S. had a moral obligation to grant full citizenship to African Americans.
• Fugitive Slave Acts and Black Refugees: Laws that allowed the capture and return of runaway enslaved people. Many Black abolitionists sought refuge in England and Ireland to escape recapture and continue their fight for abolition.
  • Notable figures who found refuge included Henry Box Brown and William Wells Brown.
• Paradox of American Independence: The contradiction of celebrating freedom and independence while denying African Americans basic rights and citizenship.
  • The Dred Scott decision (1857) ruled that African Americans could not be U.S. citizens, further highlighting the hypocrisy of American ideals of freedom.
  • Abolitionists like Douglass and Sojourner Truth pointed out that the U.S. prospered at the expense of enslaved African American labor.