Fiveable

🧑🏻‍💼United States Law and Legal Analysis Unit 1 Review

QR code for United States Law and Legal Analysis practice questions

1.1 Structure of the U.S. Constitution

🧑🏻‍💼United States Law and Legal Analysis
Unit 1 Review

1.1 Structure of the U.S. Constitution

Written by the Fiveable Content Team • Last updated September 2025
Written by the Fiveable Content Team • Last updated September 2025
🧑🏻‍💼United States Law and Legal Analysis
Unit & Topic Study Guides

The U.S. Constitution forms the backbone of American law, establishing a system of government with three branches and a balance of powers. It outlines fundamental rights, sets up a federal system, and provides a framework for interpreting and applying laws.

The Constitution's structure includes seven articles and 27 amendments. It divides power between federal and state governments, establishes checks and balances, and protects individual liberties through the Bill of Rights. This framework shapes all aspects of U.S. law and legal analysis.

Framework of the Constitution

  • Provides the fundamental structure and principles for the United States government system
  • Establishes a balance between federal authority and individual rights
  • Serves as the supreme law of the land, guiding all aspects of American law and legal analysis

Articles and amendments

  • Seven original articles form the Constitution's core structure
  • Outlines the three branches of government (legislative, executive, judicial)
  • 27 amendments added since ratification address evolving societal needs
  • First ten amendments (Bill of Rights) protect fundamental individual liberties
  • Later amendments expand voting rights, alter government procedures, and address civil rights

Separation of powers

  • Divides government authority among three distinct branches
  • Legislative branch (Congress) makes laws
  • Executive branch (President) enforces laws
  • Judicial branch (Supreme Court and federal courts) interprets laws
  • Prevents concentration of power in any single entity or individual
  • Promotes accountability and reduces risk of tyranny

Checks and balances

  • System allowing each branch to limit the powers of the others
  • Congress can override presidential vetoes with a two-thirds majority
  • President nominates Supreme Court justices, subject to Senate confirmation
  • Supreme Court can declare laws unconstitutional through judicial review
  • Ensures no branch becomes too powerful or acts outside its constitutional authority

Preamble and purpose

  • Introduces the Constitution and sets forth its fundamental goals
  • Provides context for interpreting the document's subsequent provisions
  • Emphasizes the Constitution's role in establishing a more perfect union

Goals of the Constitution

  • Establish justice through a fair and impartial legal system
  • Ensure domestic tranquility by maintaining peace and order within the nation
  • Provide for the common defense to protect against external threats
  • Promote the general welfare by fostering conditions for citizens' well-being
  • Secure the blessings of liberty for present and future generations
  • Create a more perfect union by addressing flaws in the Articles of Confederation

Significance of "We the People"

  • Declares the Constitution's authority derives from the citizens, not a monarch or ruling class
  • Emphasizes the principle of popular sovereignty
  • Reflects the idea of a government by consent of the governed
  • Establishes the United States as a representative democracy
  • Reinforces the concept that government officials serve the people, not rule over them

Legislative branch

  • Established in Article I of the Constitution
  • Responsible for creating, debating, and passing federal laws
  • Plays a crucial role in the system of checks and balances

Powers of Congress

  • Levy taxes and regulate commerce
  • Declare war and maintain armed forces
  • Coin money and regulate its value
  • Establish federal courts inferior to the Supreme Court
  • Impeach and remove federal officials from office
  • Ratify treaties and confirm presidential appointments
  • Create and abolish executive departments

House vs Senate

  • House of Representatives
    • 435 members apportioned based on state population
    • Two-year terms for all representatives
    • Exclusive power to initiate revenue bills
  • Senate
    • 100 members (two per state) regardless of population
    • Six-year terms with staggered elections
    • Exclusive power to confirm presidential appointments and ratify treaties
  • Bicameral structure balances interests of large and small states

Legislative process

  • Bill introduction by a member of Congress
  • Committee consideration and possible amendments
  • Floor debate and voting in the chamber of origin
  • If passed, repeats process in the other chamber
  • Conference committee resolves differences between House and Senate versions
  • Final version must pass both chambers
  • Presented to the President for signature or veto
  • Can become law without signature after 10 days (excluding Sundays) if Congress is in session

Executive branch

  • Established in Article II of the Constitution
  • Responsible for enforcing and executing federal laws
  • Headed by the President of the United States

Presidential powers

  • Serve as Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces
  • Grant pardons and reprieves for federal offenses
  • Nominate federal judges and Supreme Court justices
  • Appoint Cabinet members and other high-ranking officials
  • Negotiate treaties (subject to Senate ratification)
  • Veto legislation passed by Congress
  • Deliver State of the Union address to Congress

Cabinet and executive agencies

  • Cabinet advises the President on various policy matters
  • Consists of heads of executive departments (State, Defense, Treasury)
  • Executive agencies implement and enforce federal laws and regulations
  • Include independent agencies (CIA, EPA) and executive departments
  • Presidents appoint agency heads, subject to Senate confirmation
  • Agencies create rules and regulations under authority delegated by Congress

Executive orders

  • Directives issued by the President to federal agencies and officials
  • Carry the force of law but do not require congressional approval
  • Used to implement policies within the executive branch
  • Can be challenged in court or overturned by subsequent presidents
  • Subject to judicial review for constitutionality
  • Examples include desegregation of the military and establishing national monuments

Judicial branch

  • Established in Article III of the Constitution
  • Interprets laws and determines their constitutionality
  • Resolves disputes between parties at the federal level

Supreme Court structure

  • Highest court in the United States
  • Consists of nine justices, including one Chief Justice
  • Justices appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate
  • Serve life terms, removable only through impeachment
  • Decides cases by majority vote
  • Issues written opinions explaining legal reasoning behind decisions

Federal court system

  • District courts (94) serve as trial courts for federal cases
  • Circuit courts of appeals (13) hear appeals from district courts
  • Supreme Court has discretionary review over most cases
  • Specialized courts (bankruptcy, tax) handle specific types of cases
  • Federal judges appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate
  • Article III judges have life tenure and protected salaries

Judicial review

  • Power to declare laws unconstitutional, established in Marbury v. Madison (1803)
  • Allows courts to strike down laws that conflict with the Constitution
  • Applies to federal, state, and local laws and actions
  • Serves as a crucial check on legislative and executive powers
  • Controversial due to potential for "judicial activism"
  • Central to the evolution of constitutional law and interpretation

Federalism

  • System of government dividing power between national and state governments
  • Established by the Constitution to balance national unity and state autonomy
  • Crucial concept in United States law and legal analysis

State vs federal powers

  • Federal powers enumerated in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution
  • Include regulating interstate commerce, coining money, declaring war
  • State powers include education, law enforcement, intrastate commerce
  • Concurrent powers shared by both (taxation, establishing courts)
  • Elastic clause allows Congress to make laws "necessary and proper" for executing its powers
  • Tenth Amendment reserves powers not delegated to the federal government to the states

Supremacy clause

  • Article VI, Clause 2 of the Constitution
  • Establishes federal law as the "supreme law of the land"
  • Federal laws and treaties take precedence over conflicting state laws
  • Applies only when federal law is constitutional and within Congress's enumerated powers
  • Does not automatically invalidate all state laws in a given area
  • Courts use preemption doctrine to resolve conflicts between state and federal laws

Reserved powers

  • Powers not specifically granted to the federal government or prohibited to the states
  • Protected by the Tenth Amendment
  • Include regulating intrastate commerce, establishing local governments
  • Conducting elections, ratifying constitutional amendments
  • Exercising police power to protect public health, safety, and welfare
  • Creating state constitutions and laws not conflicting with federal law

Bill of Rights

  • First ten amendments to the Constitution
  • Ratified in 1791 to protect individual liberties and limit government power
  • Applies to federal government originally, later incorporated to states via 14th Amendment

First Amendment freedoms

  • Freedom of speech protects expression from government censorship
  • Freedom of religion prohibits establishment of state religion and protects free exercise
  • Freedom of the press safeguards media from government interference
  • Right to peaceably assemble allows for public gatherings and protests
  • Right to petition the government for redress of grievances
  • These freedoms form the foundation of American civil liberties

Due process clauses

  • Found in Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments
  • Procedural due process ensures fair procedures when government deprives life, liberty, or property
  • Substantive due process protects fundamental rights from government interference
  • Fifth Amendment applies to federal government
  • Fourteenth Amendment extends due process protections to state actions
  • Key concept in protecting individual rights and limiting government power

Criminal procedure protections

  • Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures
  • Fifth Amendment provides right against self-incrimination and double jeopardy protection
  • Sixth Amendment guarantees right to speedy and public trial, impartial jury, and counsel
  • Eighth Amendment prohibits excessive bail, fines, and cruel and unusual punishment
  • Miranda v. Arizona (1966) requires police to inform suspects of their rights
  • Exclusionary rule prevents use of illegally obtained evidence in court

Constitutional amendments

  • Mechanism for adapting the Constitution to changing societal needs and values
  • 27 amendments ratified since Constitution's adoption
  • Process outlined in Article V of the Constitution

Amendment process

  • Proposal requires two-thirds majority in both houses of Congress
  • Alternative method allows two-thirds of state legislatures to call a constitutional convention
  • Ratification requires approval by three-fourths of state legislatures or state conventions
  • Time limit for ratification may be set by Congress (typically seven years)
  • President has no formal role in the amendment process
  • Designed to be difficult to prevent frequent or hasty changes to the Constitution

Key amendments beyond Bill of Rights

  • 13th Amendment abolished slavery and involuntary servitude
  • 14th Amendment granted citizenship to former slaves, equal protection of laws
  • 15th Amendment prohibited denial of voting rights based on race
  • 19th Amendment granted women the right to vote
  • 22nd Amendment limited presidents to two terms
  • 26th Amendment lowered voting age to 18

Failed amendments

  • Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) fell short of ratification deadline
  • Proposed amendments to ban flag desecration
  • Attempts to define marriage as between a man and woman
  • Balanced budget amendment proposals
  • Term limits for members of Congress
  • District of Columbia statehood amendment

Interpretation methods

  • Approaches used by judges and scholars to understand and apply constitutional provisions
  • Crucial in determining how the Constitution adapts to modern issues
  • Influence judicial decisions and shape constitutional law

Originalism vs living Constitution

  • Originalism
    • Interprets Constitution based on original public meaning or framers' intent
    • Advocates argue it provides stability and limits judicial activism
    • Critics claim it's too rigid and ignores societal changes
  • Living Constitution
    • Views Constitution as adaptable to contemporary needs and values
    • Supporters argue it allows Constitution to remain relevant
    • Detractors worry it gives judges too much power to "rewrite" the Constitution

Textualism vs purposivism

  • Textualism
    • Focuses on the plain meaning of the constitutional text
    • Emphasizes dictionary definitions and linguistic context
    • Aims to limit judicial discretion and promote predictability
  • Purposivism
    • Considers the purpose or intent behind constitutional provisions
    • Examines historical context and framers' goals
    • Allows for more flexible interpretation to achieve intended outcomes

Judicial activism vs restraint

  • Judicial activism
    • Judges more willing to overturn precedents or strike down laws
    • Advocates argue it protects rights and adapts to changing times
    • Critics claim it usurps legislative authority
  • Judicial restraint
    • Judges defer more to other branches and precedent
    • Supporters say it respects separation of powers and democracy
    • Detractors argue it can allow unconstitutional laws to stand

Constitutional challenges

  • Legal actions questioning the constitutionality of laws, regulations, or government actions
  • Essential mechanism for enforcing constitutional limits on government power
  • Key component of the American legal system and constitutional law

Standing and justiciability

  • Standing requires plaintiff to show concrete injury, causation, and redressability
  • Prohibits advisory opinions on hypothetical issues
  • Mootness doctrine prevents courts from deciding cases no longer in controversy
  • Ripeness ensures cases are ready for judicial review
  • Political question doctrine limits court involvement in issues best left to other branches
  • These doctrines ensure courts only decide actual cases or controversies

Levels of scrutiny

  • Strict scrutiny
    • Applied to laws affecting fundamental rights or suspect classifications
    • Government must show compelling interest and narrow tailoring
    • Used for racial discrimination, content-based speech restrictions
  • Intermediate scrutiny
    • Applied to quasi-suspect classifications (gender)
    • Government must show important interest and substantial relation
  • Rational basis review
    • Default standard for most laws
    • Government action must be rationally related to legitimate interest
    • Highly deferential to legislature

Burden of proof

  • Challenger typically bears initial burden of proving unconstitutionality
  • Government bears burden of justification under heightened scrutiny
  • Presumption of constitutionality for duly enacted laws
  • Clear and convincing evidence often required to overcome this presumption
  • Facial challenges (law always unconstitutional) face higher burden than as-applied challenges
  • Burden may shift depending on nature of right and level of scrutiny applied

Evolution of constitutional law

  • Ongoing process of interpreting and applying the Constitution to new situations
  • Shaped by Supreme Court decisions, societal changes, and political developments
  • Reflects the dynamic nature of American law and legal analysis

Landmark Supreme Court cases

  • Marbury v. Madison (1803) established judicial review
  • McCulloch v. Maryland (1819) affirmed broad federal powers under Necessary and Proper Clause
  • Brown v. Board of Education (1954) overturned racial segregation in public schools
  • Roe v. Wade (1973) recognized constitutional right to abortion
  • United States v. Lopez (1995) limited Congress's power under Commerce Clause
  • Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) legalized same-sex marriage nationwide

Constitutional crises

  • Civil War challenged the nature of the Union and federal authority
  • Watergate scandal tested limits of executive privilege and presidential power
  • Impeachment proceedings (Johnson, Clinton, Trump) explored removal process
  • 2000 election dispute in Bush v. Gore highlighted electoral process issues
  • Post-9/11 policies raised questions about balancing security and civil liberties
  • COVID-19 pandemic sparked debates over federal and state emergency powers

Modern constitutional debates

  • Scope of Second Amendment rights and gun control
  • Limits of presidential power in foreign affairs and national security
  • Extent of federal power under Commerce Clause
  • Balancing free speech with concerns over hate speech and misinformation
  • Privacy rights in the digital age and government surveillance
  • Voting rights and election law challenges
  • Affirmative action and racial preferences in education and employment