Fiveable

๐Ÿช„Political Philosophy Unit 5 Review

QR code for Political Philosophy practice questions

5.1 Hobbes and the Leviathan: absolute sovereignty

๐Ÿช„Political Philosophy
Unit 5 Review

5.1 Hobbes and the Leviathan: absolute sovereignty

Written by the Fiveable Content Team โ€ข Last updated September 2025
Written by the Fiveable Content Team โ€ข Last updated September 2025
๐Ÿช„Political Philosophy
Unit & Topic Study Guides

Thomas Hobbes's "Leviathan" introduces the concept of absolute sovereignty as a solution to the chaos of the state of nature. He argues that humans, driven by self-interest, need a powerful ruler to maintain order and peace.

Hobbes's social contract theory proposes that individuals surrender their natural rights to an all-powerful sovereign. This trade-off between freedom and security forms the basis of his political philosophy, influencing later thinkers in the social contract tradition.

Hobbes' State of Nature

The Absence of Government and Laws

  • Thomas Hobbes, an English philosopher, developed a theory about the state of nature, a hypothetical condition of humanity before the formation of organized societies and governments
  • In the state of nature, there are no laws, no government, and no social order to regulate human behavior or protect individuals from harm
  • Without a central authority to enforce rules and maintain peace, the state of nature is characterized by a constant state of war, where every person is in competition with others for resources and survival
  • Hobbes argues that in the absence of government, human life would be "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short" due to the constant threat of violence and conflict

The Pursuit of Self-Preservation

  • In the state of nature, Hobbes believes that the primary motivation for human behavior is self-preservation, the instinctive desire to protect one's own life and well-being
  • Individuals have natural rights, which are the inherent freedoms and liberties that all people possess in the state of nature, such as the right to life and the right to defend oneself
  • However, the unrestricted exercise of natural rights leads to a "war of all against all," as people compete for limited resources and seek to protect themselves from others who may pose a threat
  • In this state of constant conflict, individuals are willing to do whatever is necessary to ensure their own survival, even if it means harming or exploiting others

The Need for a Social Contract

  • To escape the dangers and instability of the state of nature, Hobbes argues that individuals must enter into a social contract, an agreement among people to surrender some of their natural rights to a sovereign authority in exchange for protection and security
  • By giving up certain freedoms and submitting to the rule of a powerful sovereign, individuals can escape the constant fear and violence of the state of nature and enjoy the benefits of living in a stable, organized society
  • The social contract is a voluntary agreement, but once entered into, it is binding and irrevocable, as the sovereign authority must have absolute power to maintain order and prevent a return to the state of nature

The Social Contract

The Leviathan and Absolute Sovereignty

  • In his book "Leviathan," Hobbes presents his vision of the ideal government that emerges from the social contract, a powerful sovereign authority that he calls the "Leviathan"
  • The Leviathan is an absolute monarch or ruling body that possesses complete and unquestioned authority over its subjects, with the power to make and enforce laws, maintain order, and protect the people from internal and external threats
  • Hobbes argues that the sovereign must have absolute sovereignty, meaning that its power is indivisible, unlimited, and not subject to any higher authority or legal constraints
  • The sovereign is not bound by the laws it creates and cannot be held accountable by the people, as any attempt to limit or challenge its authority would undermine the stability and security of the state

The Necessity of an Authoritarian Government

  • Hobbes believes that the most effective form of government for maintaining order and preventing a return to the state of nature is an authoritarian regime, where power is concentrated in the hands of a single ruler or small group of leaders
  • An authoritarian government can act decisively and efficiently to suppress dissent, punish lawbreakers, and protect the interests of the state, without being hindered by the competing demands of different factions or the need for popular consent
  • While Hobbes acknowledges that an authoritarian government may sometimes act in ways that are harsh or oppressive, he argues that this is preferable to the chaos and violence of the state of nature
  • The subjects of the Leviathan must obey its commands and accept its decisions, even if they disagree with them, as the alternative is a return to the war of all against all and the constant threat of death and destruction

The Trade-Off Between Freedom and Security

  • The social contract that Hobbes describes involves a trade-off between individual freedom and collective security, as people must surrender some of their natural rights and liberties to the sovereign in order to gain the benefits of living in a stable, organized society
  • While critics of Hobbes argue that his vision of government is too authoritarian and leaves no room for individual rights or democratic participation, he maintains that the alternative is far worse, as the state of nature is a condition of perpetual conflict and insecurity
  • Hobbes believes that the primary purpose of government is to provide safety and stability, and that this can only be achieved through the exercise of absolute power and the strict enforcement of laws and social norms
  • The social contract may limit individual freedom in certain ways, but it also creates the conditions for people to pursue their own interests and live in relative peace and prosperity, free from the constant fear of violence and death that characterizes the state of nature