Fiveable

๐Ÿ“–Philosophical Texts Unit 6 Review

QR code for Philosophical Texts practice questions

6.4 Kierkegaard and Existentialism

๐Ÿ“–Philosophical Texts
Unit 6 Review

6.4 Kierkegaard and Existentialism

Written by the Fiveable Content Team โ€ข Last updated September 2025
Written by the Fiveable Content Team โ€ข Last updated September 2025
๐Ÿ“–Philosophical Texts
Unit & Topic Study Guides

Kierkegaard's philosophy shook up 19th-century thought by focusing on individual existence and subjective truth. He challenged Hegel's systematic approach, emphasizing personal responsibility and the limits of rational thinking in understanding human experience.

Kierkegaard's ideas on faith, anxiety, and authenticity laid the groundwork for existentialism. His use of pseudonyms and literary devices to explore philosophical concepts influenced later thinkers and writers, reshaping how we approach questions of meaning and existence.

Key Concepts in Kierkegaard's Philosophy

The Individual and Subjective Truth

  • Kierkegaard's concept of the "individual" emphasizes personal responsibility and subjective truth over objective systems
  • Three stages of existence represent different levels of self-awareness and commitment
    • Aesthetic stage focuses on immediate pleasure and avoidance of boredom
    • Ethical stage involves commitment to moral principles and societal norms
    • Religious stage represents the highest form of existence, characterized by a personal relationship with God
  • Notion of "anxiety" stems from the freedom to choose and the burden of responsibility
    • Manifests as a feeling of dizziness or vertigo when confronted with infinite possibilities
    • Serves as a catalyst for personal growth and self-discovery
  • Concept of "despair" understood as a misrelation of the self to itself and to the power that established it
    • Three forms of despair: unconscious, conscious but unwilling to change, and defiant despair
    • Can only be overcome through faith and acceptance of one's true self

Faith and Indirect Communication

  • Emphasis on the "passion of faith" as a subjective, inward experience beyond rational argumentation
    • Involves a personal commitment to believe in the face of uncertainty and paradox
    • Exemplified by the biblical figure of Abraham in Kierkegaard's work "Fear and Trembling"
  • Idea of "indirect communication" uses pseudonyms and literary devices to engage readers in self-reflection
    • Pseudonyms include Victor Eremita, Johannes de Silentio, and Anti-Climacus
    • Literary styles range from philosophical treatises to fictional narratives and diary entries
  • Kierkegaard's writing aims to provoke existential questioning rather than provide definitive answers
    • Encourages readers to confront their own beliefs and values
    • Challenges conventional modes of philosophical discourse

Kierkegaard's Critique of Hegelian Idealism

Rejection of Systematic Philosophy

  • Kierkegaard rejects Hegel's systematic philosophy and the notion of absolute knowledge attainable through reason alone
    • Argues that existence cannot be fully captured by abstract concepts or logical systems
    • Emphasizes the limitations of rational thought in understanding human experience
  • Critiques Hegel's view of history as a rational, necessary process
    • Contrasts with Kierkegaard's emphasis on individual choice and contingency
    • Argues that historical events are shaped by free will and cannot be predetermined
  • Distinguishes between "objective" and "subjective" truth
    • Objective truth relates to facts and logical propositions
    • Subjective truth concerns personal beliefs and commitments essential for authentic existence

The Leap of Faith and Ethical Suspension

  • Concept of the "leap of faith" involves a radical commitment transcending rational justification and objective certainty
    • Requires embracing paradox and uncertainty in religious belief
    • Contrasts with attempts to prove religious truths through logical arguments
  • Argues that faith involves a "teleological suspension of the ethical"
    • Uses the example of Abraham in "Fear and Trembling" to illustrate this concept
    • Challenges the idea that ethical norms are absolute and universally applicable
  • Critiques speculative philosophy's attempt to "go beyond" faith
    • Asserts that faith is the highest stage of human existence
    • Argues against the rationalization of religious belief

Kierkegaard's Influence on Existentialism

Foundations of Existentialist Thought

  • Kierkegaard's role as a precursor to 20th-century Existentialism emphasizes individual existence and subjective truth
    • Influenced philosophers such as Jean-Paul Sartre, Albert Camus, and Martin Heidegger
    • Laid groundwork for existentialist focus on personal experience and meaning
  • Concept of anxiety impacts later existentialist thinkers
    • Heidegger develops the idea of "Angst" as a fundamental mood of human existence
    • Sartre explores anxiety in relation to radical freedom and responsibility
  • Kierkegaard's influence on the existentialist theme of authenticity shapes ideas about personal identity
    • Emphasizes the importance of making genuine choices and commitments
    • Critiques societal conformity and inauthenticity

Existentialist Themes and Strategies

  • Development of existentialist ideas of freedom and responsibility rooted in Kierkegaard's emphasis on individual agency
    • Sartre's concept of radical freedom builds on Kierkegaard's notion of choice
    • Existentialist ethics emphasize personal responsibility for one's actions and beliefs
  • Critique of societal norms and "the crowd" forms foundation for later existentialist social criticism
    • Influences existentialist analyses of alienation and conformity
    • Informs existentialist discussions of authenticity in social contexts
  • Incorporation of Kierkegaard's literary and rhetorical strategies by existentialist philosophers and writers
    • Use of fictional narratives and characters to explore philosophical ideas (Sartre's "Nausea", Camus' "The Stranger")
    • Emphasis on paradox and irony as tools for philosophical reflection

Kierkegaard's Significance in 19th-Century Thought

Challenging Philosophical Traditions

  • Kierkegaard's challenge to dominant Hegelian philosophy impacts subsequent philosophical discourse
    • Shifts focus from abstract systems to concrete human existence
    • Influences development of phenomenology and hermeneutics
  • Role in the shift from systematic philosophy to more individualistic and experiential approaches
    • Anticipates philosophical movements emphasizing lived experience (phenomenology)
    • Contributes to the development of existential psychology and psychoanalysis
  • Contribution to the critique of organized religion emphasizes a personal, inward relationship with God
    • Influences Protestant theology and the development of neo-orthodoxy
    • Challenges traditional religious institutions and dogmas

Literary Innovation and Cultural Impact

  • Significance of Kierkegaard's pseudonymous writings as a novel approach to philosophical authorship in the 19th century
    • Introduces multiple perspectives and voices within a single author's work
    • Blurs boundaries between philosophy and literature
  • Influence on the development of Christian existentialism and dialectical theology in the 20th century
    • Impacts theologians such as Karl Barth and Paul Tillich
    • Contributes to existential interpretations of Christian doctrine
  • Relevance to broader intellectual and cultural context of 19th-century Europe
    • Engages with Romantic themes of individuality and subjective experience
    • Addresses challenges of emerging modernity (secularization, industrialization)
  • Anticipation of key themes in 20th-century philosophy
    • Influences development of phenomenology (Husserl, Heidegger)
    • Contributes to hermeneutic approaches to textual interpretation
    • Foreshadows postmodern critiques of grand narratives and absolute truth claims