Fiveable

🏹Native American History Unit 4 Review

QR code for Native American History practice questions

4.1 Manifest Destiny

🏹Native American History
Unit 4 Review

4.1 Manifest Destiny

Written by the Fiveable Content Team • Last updated September 2025
Written by the Fiveable Content Team • Last updated September 2025
🏹Native American History
Unit & Topic Study Guides

Manifest Destiny shaped 19th-century American expansion westward, profoundly impacting Native communities. This ideology justified territorial acquisition as a divine right, intertwining with notions of racial superiority and cultural dominance over indigenous peoples.

The concept led to massive territorial expansion, including the Louisiana Purchase, Oregon Territory, and Mexican-American War acquisitions. These land grabs resulted in forced relocations, cultural disruption, and devastating consequences for Native American populations across the continent.

Origins of Manifest Destiny

  • Manifest Destiny shaped 19th century American expansion westward, profoundly impacting Native American communities
  • Ideology justified territorial acquisition as a divine right and duty of the United States
  • Concept intertwined with notions of racial superiority and cultural dominance over indigenous peoples

Concept of American exceptionalism

  • Belief in the unique virtues and destiny of the United States
  • Portrayed America as a model nation with a mission to spread democracy and civilization
  • Justified expansion as a means to extend American institutions and values
  • Reinforced ideas of cultural and racial superiority over Native Americans
  • Influenced foreign policy and domestic attitudes towards indigenous populations

Influence of Jacksonian democracy

  • Emphasized popular sovereignty and expanded voting rights for white males
  • Promoted agrarian ideals and individual land ownership
  • Encouraged westward expansion as a means of economic opportunity
  • Supported removal of Native Americans to make way for white settlers
  • Reinforced the notion of "common man's democracy" at the expense of indigenous rights

Religious and moral justifications

  • Invoked divine providence as sanction for territorial expansion
  • Framed westward movement as a civilizing mission to "tame" the wilderness
  • Used Protestant Christianity to justify conversion and assimilation of Native peoples
  • Employed the concept of "Manifest Destiny" coined by John L. O'Sullivan in 1845
  • Portrayed expansion as a moral obligation to spread American values and institutions

Territorial expansion westward

  • Westward expansion dramatically reshaped the North American continent in the 19th century
  • Acquisition of vast territories led to displacement and conflict with Native American nations
  • Process fundamentally altered the balance of power between the U.S. and indigenous peoples

Louisiana Purchase implications

  • Doubled the size of the United States in 1803
  • Opened vast new territories for American settlement and exploration
  • Increased pressure on Native American lands east of the Mississippi River
  • Facilitated further westward expansion and encounters with new indigenous nations
  • Led to the Lewis and Clark expedition, mapping and documenting western territories

Oregon Territory dispute

  • Contested region between the United States and Great Britain
  • Slogan "Fifty-four Forty or Fight" reflected American expansionist sentiment
  • Oregon Treaty of 1846 established the 49th parallel as the northern U.S. border
  • Opened Pacific Northwest to American settlement, impacting local Native tribes (Chinook, Nez Perce)
  • Intensified conflicts over land and resources between settlers and indigenous peoples

Mexican-American War consequences

  • Resulted in the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo in 1848
  • Acquired nearly half of Mexico's territory, including California and the Southwest
  • Brought diverse Native American groups under U.S. control (Apache, Navajo, Pueblo)
  • Intensified debates over the expansion of slavery into new territories
  • Accelerated the pace of westward expansion and settlement

Impact on Native Americans

  • Manifest Destiny had devastating consequences for Native American populations
  • Policies of removal and relocation disrupted traditional ways of life and social structures
  • Expansion led to loss of ancestral lands and resources crucial for indigenous survival

Forced relocation policies

  • Indian Removal Act of 1830 authorized the relocation of eastern tribes
  • Five Civilized Tribes (Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek, Seminole) forcibly moved west
  • Establishment of Indian Territory (present-day Oklahoma) as designated Native land
  • Broken treaties and coerced agreements used to justify removals
  • Resulted in significant loss of life, cultural disruption, and economic hardship

Trail of Tears

  • Forced relocation of Cherokee Nation from southeastern U.S. to Indian Territory
  • Approximately 15,000 Cherokee people marched over 1,000 miles
  • Harsh conditions led to thousands of deaths from disease, starvation, and exposure
  • Exemplified the human cost of Manifest Destiny and Indian removal policies
  • Became a symbol of Native American suffering and resistance to forced relocation

Breakdown of tribal sovereignty

  • U.S. government increasingly interfered with internal tribal affairs
  • Imposed American legal and political systems on Native nations
  • Undermined traditional leadership structures and decision-making processes
  • Restricted Native Americans' ability to manage their own lands and resources
  • Led to dependence on federal government for basic needs and services

Cultural and social effects

  • Manifest Destiny profoundly shaped American cultural identity and social attitudes
  • Created enduring stereotypes and misconceptions about Native American cultures
  • Influenced literature, art, and popular perceptions of the American West

Romanticization of the frontier

  • Portrayed the West as an untamed wilderness ripe for conquest
  • Celebrated pioneer spirit and rugged individualism
  • Depicted Native Americans as obstacles to progress or noble savages
  • Inspired works of art and literature (paintings of Albert Bierstadt, novels of James Fenimore Cooper)
  • Reinforced the narrative of manifest destiny and American exceptionalism

Myth of the vanishing Indian

  • Perpetuated the idea that Native Americans were destined to disappear
  • Justified policies of removal and assimilation as inevitable historical processes
  • Ignored the resilience and adaptability of indigenous cultures
  • Influenced representations in popular culture and academic discourse
  • Contributed to the erasure of Native American perspectives from historical narratives

Anglo-American vs Native worldviews

  • Contrasted individualistic, property-based Anglo-American values with communal Native traditions
  • Emphasized different concepts of land ownership and resource management
  • Highlighted conflicting spiritual and religious beliefs (Christianity vs indigenous spirituality)
  • Reflected divergent approaches to nature and environmental stewardship
  • Resulted in misunderstandings and conflicts over treaty rights and obligations

Economic motivations

  • Economic factors played a crucial role in driving westward expansion
  • Manifest Destiny provided ideological justification for economic exploitation of new territories
  • Expansion created opportunities and conflicts related to land, resources, and development

Land speculation and settlement

  • Government land sales and homesteading encouraged westward migration
  • Speculators acquired large tracts of land for resale at higher prices
  • Displaced Native Americans from traditional hunting and agricultural lands
  • Created conflicts over land rights and resource access
  • Led to the establishment of new towns, farms, and ranches across the West

Resource exploitation

  • Discovery of gold and other minerals sparked rushes (California Gold Rush of 1849)
  • Timber harvesting in the Pacific Northwest supported eastward expansion
  • Overhunting of buffalo disrupted Plains Indian economies and cultures
  • Mining and resource extraction often occurred on or near Native American lands
  • Led to environmental degradation and depletion of resources crucial to indigenous communities

Transcontinental railroad development

  • Facilitated rapid transportation and communication across the continent
  • Completed in 1869, linking eastern and western United States
  • Accelerated westward migration and settlement
  • Disrupted Native American territories and traditional migration routes
  • Contributed to the near-extinction of the American bison, a key resource for Plains tribes

Political ramifications

  • Manifest Destiny shaped American political discourse and policy-making
  • Expansion exacerbated existing tensions and created new political challenges
  • Policies towards Native Americans became increasingly centralized and interventionist

Sectional tensions and slavery

  • Debates over the expansion of slavery into new territories intensified
  • Missouri Compromise of 1820 and Compromise of 1850 attempted to maintain balance
  • Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 led to violent conflicts over slavery in new territories
  • Contributed to growing divisions between North and South, leading to Civil War
  • Impacted Native American alliances and involvement in broader national conflicts

Indian Removal Act of 1830

  • Authorized the president to negotiate removal treaties with eastern tribes
  • Passed under Andrew Jackson's administration, reflecting Jacksonian democracy ideals
  • Led to forced relocations of numerous tribes to lands west of the Mississippi
  • Resulted in significant loss of life and cultural disruption for affected tribes
  • Set a precedent for future policies of Native American displacement and containment

Treaty-making and violations

  • U.S. government entered into numerous treaties with Native American nations
  • Treaties often used to acquire land and resources from indigenous peoples
  • Many treaties violated or unilaterally abrogated by the U.S. government
  • Created ongoing legal and political disputes over land rights and sovereignty
  • Undermined trust between Native American nations and the federal government

Resistance and adaptation

  • Native American communities actively resisted and adapted to the pressures of Manifest Destiny
  • Various strategies employed to maintain cultural identity and defend territorial rights
  • Resistance took forms ranging from armed conflict to legal and diplomatic efforts

Native American alliances

  • Tribes formed coalitions to resist encroachment and defend territories
  • Tecumseh's Confederacy united tribes against American expansion in early 1800s
  • Intertribal cooperation increased in face of common threats (Lakota-Cheyenne alliance)
  • Some tribes allied with European powers to counter American influence (War of 1812)
  • Alliances often transcended traditional tribal boundaries and rivalries

Armed conflicts and wars

  • Numerous wars fought between Native Americans and U.S. forces (Seminole Wars, Plains Indian Wars)
  • Battle of Little Bighorn (1876) saw victory of Lakota, Northern Cheyenne, and Arapaho forces
  • Nez Perce War (1877) led by Chief Joseph in attempt to resist relocation
  • Ghost Dance movement of 1890 culminated in Wounded Knee Massacre
  • Armed resistance ultimately suppressed by superior U.S. military technology and numbers

Cultural preservation efforts

  • Native communities developed strategies to maintain languages and traditions
  • Oral histories and storytelling preserved cultural knowledge and tribal histories
  • Adaptation of traditional practices to new circumstances (reservation life)
  • Development of pan-Indian movements to unite diverse tribes (Native American Church)
  • Efforts to protect sacred sites and maintain spiritual practices despite restrictions

Legacy and modern perspectives

  • Manifest Destiny's impact continues to shape contemporary Native American issues
  • Critical reassessment of the ideology and its consequences in modern scholarship
  • Ongoing struggles for indigenous rights and cultural revitalization

Critique of Manifest Destiny

  • Scholars and activists challenge the moral and ethical basis of the ideology
  • Recognition of Manifest Destiny's role in genocide and cultural destruction
  • Reexamination of historical narratives to include Native American perspectives
  • Acknowledgment of the environmental consequences of rapid westward expansion
  • Discussions of intergenerational trauma and lasting impacts on indigenous communities

Ongoing land disputes

  • Continued legal battles over treaty rights and land ownership
  • Conflicts over resource extraction on or near Native American lands (Dakota Access Pipeline)
  • Efforts to reclaim ancestral territories and sacred sites
  • Debates over federal recognition and its implications for land rights
  • Environmental concerns related to land use and preservation of traditional territories

Native American rights movements

  • Activism for indigenous sovereignty and self-determination
  • American Indian Movement (AIM) founded in 1968 to address civil rights issues
  • Push for greater tribal control over education, healthcare, and economic development
  • Efforts to revitalize Native languages and cultural practices
  • Advocacy for accurate representation in media, education, and public discourse