Fiveable

🍁History of Canada – Before 1867 Unit 5 Review

QR code for History of Canada – Before 1867 practice questions

5.3 The Fathers of Confederation and their Vision for Canada

🍁History of Canada – Before 1867
Unit 5 Review

5.3 The Fathers of Confederation and their Vision for Canada

Written by the Fiveable Content Team • Last updated September 2025
Written by the Fiveable Content Team • Last updated September 2025
🍁History of Canada – Before 1867
Unit & Topic Study Guides

The Fathers of Confederation were key figures who shaped Canada's future. They came from diverse backgrounds, bringing varied expertise to the table. Their vision balanced regional interests with a unified national identity.

These leaders faced challenges like American expansion and colonial dependence. They aimed to create a federal system with a strong central government, protect minority rights, and build a transcontinental railway. Their work laid the foundation for modern Canada.

Fathers of Confederation

Key Figures and Roles

  • Sir John A. Macdonald led Confederation negotiations as Conservative from Canada West
    • Became Canada's first Prime Minister
    • Skillfully balanced competing interests during negotiations
    • Advocated for a strong central government
  • George-Étienne Cartier gained French-Canadian support for Confederation
    • Represented Conservative interests from Canada East
    • Negotiated protections for French language and culture
    • Helped bridge divide between English and French Canada
  • George Brown set aside political differences to work with Macdonald
    • Led Reform Party from Canada West
    • Advocated for representation by population
    • Formed Great Coalition with Macdonald to pursue Confederation
  • Sir Charles Tupper championed Confederation in Nova Scotia
    • Later became Prime Minister of Canada in 1896
    • Overcame significant opposition in his home province
    • Negotiated favorable terms for Nova Scotia's entry
  • Sir Samuel Leonard Tilley secured New Brunswick's entry into Confederation
    • Coined term "Dominion of Canada"
    • Served as Minister of Finance in Macdonald's cabinet
    • Advocated for prohibition and temperance
  • Thomas D'Arcy McGee promoted vision of bilingual, multicultural Canada
    • Irish-Canadian politician and journalist
    • Passionate orator for Canadian nationalism
    • Assassinated in 1868, possibly by Fenian sympathizers
  • Sir Alexander Tilloch Galt contributed to Confederation's financial arrangements
    • Prominent businessman from Canada East
    • Served as first Minister of Finance of the Dominion
    • Advocated for protection of English-speaking minority rights in Quebec

Motivations of the Fathers

Diverse Backgrounds and Expertise

  • Delegates represented mix of English and French-speaking backgrounds
    • Reflected linguistic duality of future nation
    • Brought varied cultural perspectives to negotiations
  • Professional backgrounds spanned multiple fields
    • Lawyers (Macdonald, Cartier)
    • Journalists (Brown, McGee)
    • Businessmen (Galt)
    • Career politicians (Tupper)
  • Diverse expertise enriched Confederation discussions
    • Legal knowledge informed constitutional framework
    • Business acumen guided economic considerations
    • Political experience facilitated compromise

Political and Regional Interests

  • Political ideologies ranged from conservative to reform
    • Conservatives (Macdonald, Cartier) favored strong central government
    • Reformers (Brown) advocated for greater representation by population
    • Required significant compromise and coalition-building
  • Regional interests shaped delegates' priorities
    • Maritime delegates focused on economic benefits and railway connections
    • Canada West representatives sought representation by population
    • Canada East delegates prioritized protection of French-Canadian rights
  • Economic considerations motivated business-oriented delegates
    • Galt emphasized need for larger internal market
    • Improved trade relations with Britain and United States
    • Development of national infrastructure and transportation networks

Shared Motivations and Concerns

  • Fear of American expansion united delegates across ideological lines
    • Recent U.S. Civil War heightened concerns
    • Desire to maintain distinct British North American identity
  • Pursuit of greater autonomy from Britain
    • Sought to reduce colonial dependence while maintaining ties
    • Aimed to establish more self-governing federation
  • Vision of new nationality transcending ethnic and religious divisions
    • D'Arcy McGee championed inclusive Canadian identity
    • Sought to unite diverse populations under common cause

Vision for Canada

Political and Constitutional Framework

  • Federal system balancing provincial autonomy with strong central government
    • Division of powers between federal and provincial levels
    • Addressed regional concerns while fostering national unity
    • Allowed for flexibility in governance of diverse regions
  • Bicameral parliamentary system for balanced representation
    • Lower house (House of Commons) based on representation by population
    • Upper house (Senate) provided regional representation
    • Modeled on British parliamentary system with Canadian adaptations
  • Protection of minority rights enshrined in constitution
    • Safeguards for French language and culture in Quebec
    • Separate school systems for religious minorities
    • Recognition of existing treaty rights with Indigenous peoples

Economic and Infrastructure Development

  • Interprovincial trade and economic integration
    • Removal of internal trade barriers
    • Creation of unified Canadian market
    • Standardization of currency and banking systems
  • National railway system to connect provinces
    • Intercolonial Railway linking Maritimes to central Canada
    • Proposed transcontinental railway to future western territories
    • Railway as symbol of national unity and economic progress
  • Development of national industries and resources
    • Protective tariffs to encourage domestic manufacturing
    • Exploitation of natural resources across vast territory
    • Diversification of economy beyond traditional agricultural base

National Identity and Expansion

  • Creation of new Canadian nationality
    • Uniting diverse populations under common identity
    • Balancing British heritage with distinct Canadian character
    • Fostering bilingualism and cultural pluralism
  • Establishment of Canada as significant North American power
    • Capable of resisting American influence
    • Maintaining strong ties with Britain while asserting autonomy
    • Developing independent foreign policy and trade relationships
  • Westward expansion and nation-building
    • Vision of Canada stretching from "sea to sea"
    • Incorporation of Rupert's Land and North-Western Territory
    • Settlement and development of western prairies
    • Eventual addition of British Columbia to complete transcontinental nation