Fiveable
Fiveable

or

Log in

Find what you need to study


Light

Find what you need to study

1.6 Ethical Guidelines in Psychology

4 min readjanuary 5, 2023

Ashley Rossi

Ashley Rossi

Jillian Holbrook

Jillian Holbrook

Dalia Savy

Dalia Savy

Ashley Rossi

Ashley Rossi

Jillian Holbrook

Jillian Holbrook

Dalia Savy

Dalia Savy

What if stress has to be added to run an experiment? Every experiment has some sort of added stress, but how do we make sure that the potential risk to participants does not outweigh the benefits of the study? How can psychological ethics allow us to approach discussions about reasonable harm?

For example, consider a study on anxiety. The research team may need to induce anxiety in a research participant for their study, but ethics dictate how distress can be caused in a way that minimizes harm and upholds ethical values. Experiments fail if participants are biased with prior knowledge of the experimental procedure and goals, so the of psychology inform researchers how to conduct experimental research ethically.

Ethical Guidelines

These ethical and legal guidelines provided by the American Psychological Association protect research participants from unethical practices.

The on human research are: 

  • (participants must agree to participate)

  • (If is used, it must not be done in a way that invalidates ) 

  • debriefing (If was used, the researchers must explain the true purpose of the experiment after it has occurred)

  • (information about the participant will be held a secret)

  • (participants cannot be coerced to give consent to be in any study)

There are a few committees that review experiments before they are conducted to ensure that these guidelines are put in place and participants are protected:

  • The Institutional Review Board (IRB) is a committee that reviews research studies involving humans for ethics.

  • The Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) reviews research studies involving animals for ethics violations. 🐶 🐱

Unethical Experiments

In the past, there have been experiments that are now considered unethical. With these guidelines and precautions now in place, we are hoping to avoid other experiments like the and .

The Milgram Experiment

The Milgram Experiment is a very famous demonstration showing how people will obey authority figures even when they disagree. Subjects were instructed to sit in a chair and ask a learner, who was actually working with Milgram, to list pairs of words. If the learner got it wrong, a scientist would instruct the subject to deliver an electric shock to the learner.

https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-HBSsOYtjIvH4.gif?alt=media&token=15475d1b-5b6c-4e0a-899b-d7c1bd45e64f

Image Courtesy of Two Cents

It was later found that this experiment had several ethical issues. Although the learner was not actually shocked, the authority made the subject believe that they delivered electrical charges that were potentially fatal. Thus, the subject experienced the trauma of hurting another person. The participants were both harmed and deceived, especially as the debriefing did not include that the learner was never actually punished.

Harry Harlow's Monkey Experiment

Harlow and his wife Margaret bred rhesus monkeys for their research in learning. To prevent the spread of infection, they began separating young monkeys from their mothers early on. These young monkeys were typically put in a sterile cage with a baby blanket for warmth. Interestingly, Harlow noticed that when the blanket was removed to be laundered, the young monkeys became distressed.

This observation contradicted the theory that attachment stems from the need for nourishment. The blanket clearly offered no food or physical nourishment to the baby monkey, but they became attached to it nonetheless. Why was this? According to Harlow, this was because of the  the blanket provided.

To test this theory, an astoundingly unethical experiment was designed. Be warned that the following experiment contains elements of animal cruelty.

Harlow created two types of artificial mothers: one was a bare wire cylinder with a wooden head and an attached bottle for feeding (yes, it was as terrifying as it sounds). The other “mother” was wrapped in terry cloth and provided no nourishment. If, in fact,  form from the infant’s need for nourishment, then the young monkeys should prefer the wire mother with the attached bottle.

https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-7M6ESpXgJFsH.JPG?alt=media&token=a5a6b1da-6830-48a6-a32e-09e26dbe2195

Image Courtesy of Verywell Mind.

The results suggested otherwise. Young rhesus monkeys presented with both mothers overwhelmingly preferred the comfort of the terry cloth one over the wire one, despite the fact that the cloth mother provided no food. 

When the babies became stressed, they would cling to the cloth mother for comfort. When exploring, they would use the cloth mother as a , returning to her every so often after venturing out. 

The experiments became even more unethical. Harlow began to sequester young monkeys for months or years at a time with no source of attachment or interaction—only food and drink. These neglected monkeys became completely catatonic and indifferent toward their environment. In adulthood, they could not properly bond or relate with other monkeys. Female monkeys could not get pregnant since they had no interest in social interaction. Harlow had to artificially inseminate these females in order for them to reproduce. 

 

Sadly, Harlow observed that these neglected female monkeys completely ignored their babies and neglected to feed them. In some cases, the mothers even injured or killed their babies. The implication was clear: these neglected mothers could not properly love or bond with their babies.

Key Terms to Review (15)

American Psychological Association (APA)

: The APA is a scientific and professional organization that represents psychology in the United States. It's responsible for setting ethical guidelines for psychological research.

Anonymity

: Anonymity in psychology refers to the practice of ensuring that all information collected from a participant in a study is not linked to their identity, thus protecting their privacy.

Attachment Bonds

: Attachment bonds refer to the deep, enduring emotional connection that forms between individuals, typically between a child and caregiver. This bond significantly influences the child's development and ability to form relationships in the future.

Coercion

: Coercion involves forcing someone into doing something against their will, often through threats or manipulation. In psychological research, it's unethical to coerce someone into participating in a study.

Contact Comfort

: Contact comfort refers to the physical and emotional comfort that an infant receives from being in physical contact with its mother or primary caregiver.

Deception

: In psychology, deception refers to the act of misleading or lying to participants about the true purpose or nature of a study.

Deception Debriefing

: Deception debriefing involves explaining any deceptive elements and revealing the true purpose of the study to participants after it has concluded.

Ethical Guidelines

: These are rules set by professional organizations that govern the conduct of its members and provide a framework for ethical decision making.

Harry Harlow's Monkey Experiment

: A series of experiments conducted by psychologist Harry Harlow in the 1950s and 1960s on rhesus monkeys to demonstrate the importance of care-giving and companionship in social development and cognitive function.

Informed Consent

: Informed consent is an ethical principle requiring that research participants be told enough to enable them to choose whether they wish to participate.

Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC)

: The IACUC is a self-regulating entity that, according to U.S. federal law, must be established by institutions that use laboratory animals for research or instructional purposes to oversee and evaluate all aspects of the institution's animal care and use program.

Institutional Review Board (IRB)

: The IRB is an administrative body established to protect the rights and welfare of human research subjects recruited for participation in activities such as biomedical and behavioral research.

Milgram Experiment

: A series of psychological experiments conducted by Stanley Milgram which measured the willingness of participants to obey an authority figure who instructed them to perform acts conflicting with their personal conscience.

Protection from Harm or Discomfort

: This is an ethical principle in psychology that ensures participants are not subjected to physical or psychological harm during a study.

Secure Base

: A secure base refers to the concept in attachment theory where the caregiver provides a safe and reliable environment from which the child can explore their surroundings.

1.6 Ethical Guidelines in Psychology

4 min readjanuary 5, 2023

Ashley Rossi

Ashley Rossi

Jillian Holbrook

Jillian Holbrook

Dalia Savy

Dalia Savy

Ashley Rossi

Ashley Rossi

Jillian Holbrook

Jillian Holbrook

Dalia Savy

Dalia Savy

What if stress has to be added to run an experiment? Every experiment has some sort of added stress, but how do we make sure that the potential risk to participants does not outweigh the benefits of the study? How can psychological ethics allow us to approach discussions about reasonable harm?

For example, consider a study on anxiety. The research team may need to induce anxiety in a research participant for their study, but ethics dictate how distress can be caused in a way that minimizes harm and upholds ethical values. Experiments fail if participants are biased with prior knowledge of the experimental procedure and goals, so the of psychology inform researchers how to conduct experimental research ethically.

Ethical Guidelines

These ethical and legal guidelines provided by the American Psychological Association protect research participants from unethical practices.

The on human research are: 

  • (participants must agree to participate)

  • (If is used, it must not be done in a way that invalidates ) 

  • debriefing (If was used, the researchers must explain the true purpose of the experiment after it has occurred)

  • (information about the participant will be held a secret)

  • (participants cannot be coerced to give consent to be in any study)

There are a few committees that review experiments before they are conducted to ensure that these guidelines are put in place and participants are protected:

  • The Institutional Review Board (IRB) is a committee that reviews research studies involving humans for ethics.

  • The Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) reviews research studies involving animals for ethics violations. 🐶 🐱

Unethical Experiments

In the past, there have been experiments that are now considered unethical. With these guidelines and precautions now in place, we are hoping to avoid other experiments like the and .

The Milgram Experiment

The Milgram Experiment is a very famous demonstration showing how people will obey authority figures even when they disagree. Subjects were instructed to sit in a chair and ask a learner, who was actually working with Milgram, to list pairs of words. If the learner got it wrong, a scientist would instruct the subject to deliver an electric shock to the learner.

https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-HBSsOYtjIvH4.gif?alt=media&token=15475d1b-5b6c-4e0a-899b-d7c1bd45e64f

Image Courtesy of Two Cents

It was later found that this experiment had several ethical issues. Although the learner was not actually shocked, the authority made the subject believe that they delivered electrical charges that were potentially fatal. Thus, the subject experienced the trauma of hurting another person. The participants were both harmed and deceived, especially as the debriefing did not include that the learner was never actually punished.

Harry Harlow's Monkey Experiment

Harlow and his wife Margaret bred rhesus monkeys for their research in learning. To prevent the spread of infection, they began separating young monkeys from their mothers early on. These young monkeys were typically put in a sterile cage with a baby blanket for warmth. Interestingly, Harlow noticed that when the blanket was removed to be laundered, the young monkeys became distressed.

This observation contradicted the theory that attachment stems from the need for nourishment. The blanket clearly offered no food or physical nourishment to the baby monkey, but they became attached to it nonetheless. Why was this? According to Harlow, this was because of the  the blanket provided.

To test this theory, an astoundingly unethical experiment was designed. Be warned that the following experiment contains elements of animal cruelty.

Harlow created two types of artificial mothers: one was a bare wire cylinder with a wooden head and an attached bottle for feeding (yes, it was as terrifying as it sounds). The other “mother” was wrapped in terry cloth and provided no nourishment. If, in fact,  form from the infant’s need for nourishment, then the young monkeys should prefer the wire mother with the attached bottle.

https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-7M6ESpXgJFsH.JPG?alt=media&token=a5a6b1da-6830-48a6-a32e-09e26dbe2195

Image Courtesy of Verywell Mind.

The results suggested otherwise. Young rhesus monkeys presented with both mothers overwhelmingly preferred the comfort of the terry cloth one over the wire one, despite the fact that the cloth mother provided no food. 

When the babies became stressed, they would cling to the cloth mother for comfort. When exploring, they would use the cloth mother as a , returning to her every so often after venturing out. 

The experiments became even more unethical. Harlow began to sequester young monkeys for months or years at a time with no source of attachment or interaction—only food and drink. These neglected monkeys became completely catatonic and indifferent toward their environment. In adulthood, they could not properly bond or relate with other monkeys. Female monkeys could not get pregnant since they had no interest in social interaction. Harlow had to artificially inseminate these females in order for them to reproduce. 

 

Sadly, Harlow observed that these neglected female monkeys completely ignored their babies and neglected to feed them. In some cases, the mothers even injured or killed their babies. The implication was clear: these neglected mothers could not properly love or bond with their babies.

Key Terms to Review (15)

American Psychological Association (APA)

: The APA is a scientific and professional organization that represents psychology in the United States. It's responsible for setting ethical guidelines for psychological research.

Anonymity

: Anonymity in psychology refers to the practice of ensuring that all information collected from a participant in a study is not linked to their identity, thus protecting their privacy.

Attachment Bonds

: Attachment bonds refer to the deep, enduring emotional connection that forms between individuals, typically between a child and caregiver. This bond significantly influences the child's development and ability to form relationships in the future.

Coercion

: Coercion involves forcing someone into doing something against their will, often through threats or manipulation. In psychological research, it's unethical to coerce someone into participating in a study.

Contact Comfort

: Contact comfort refers to the physical and emotional comfort that an infant receives from being in physical contact with its mother or primary caregiver.

Deception

: In psychology, deception refers to the act of misleading or lying to participants about the true purpose or nature of a study.

Deception Debriefing

: Deception debriefing involves explaining any deceptive elements and revealing the true purpose of the study to participants after it has concluded.

Ethical Guidelines

: These are rules set by professional organizations that govern the conduct of its members and provide a framework for ethical decision making.

Harry Harlow's Monkey Experiment

: A series of experiments conducted by psychologist Harry Harlow in the 1950s and 1960s on rhesus monkeys to demonstrate the importance of care-giving and companionship in social development and cognitive function.

Informed Consent

: Informed consent is an ethical principle requiring that research participants be told enough to enable them to choose whether they wish to participate.

Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC)

: The IACUC is a self-regulating entity that, according to U.S. federal law, must be established by institutions that use laboratory animals for research or instructional purposes to oversee and evaluate all aspects of the institution's animal care and use program.

Institutional Review Board (IRB)

: The IRB is an administrative body established to protect the rights and welfare of human research subjects recruited for participation in activities such as biomedical and behavioral research.

Milgram Experiment

: A series of psychological experiments conducted by Stanley Milgram which measured the willingness of participants to obey an authority figure who instructed them to perform acts conflicting with their personal conscience.

Protection from Harm or Discomfort

: This is an ethical principle in psychology that ensures participants are not subjected to physical or psychological harm during a study.

Secure Base

: A secure base refers to the concept in attachment theory where the caregiver provides a safe and reliable environment from which the child can explore their surroundings.


© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.

AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.


© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.

AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.